Father Mike, as he was soon called, considered student life his top priority. He spent his first semester in fall 1974 getting to know the students—playing seven intramural sports with them, attending their plays, concerts, and sporting events, showing up at any party he heard about, invited or not.
What he discovered were many students struggling to come to terms with the dramatic cultural and moral shifts of the sixties and seventies, testing authority, and haunted by a desperate sense of loneliness and isolation. Sunday morning Mass was poorly attended, and a petition was sent to the new president requesting that it be moved to afternoon. Other petitions followed, such as a renewed demand for open dorms and an end to the campus curfew. These problems were no different from those of most Catholic and secular universities at that time.
But Father Scanlan’s response was.
Rather than merely refusing the Mass petition, Father Scanlan declared that he would be celebrating the Sunday liturgy himself. And while other administrators—even at many Catholic colleges—caved in to student petitions for co-ed dorms and against curfews, he rejected them.
Instead he inaugurated “households,” an innovative residence life program requiring students to form small groups for ongoing communal prayer, sharing, and mutual support. Despite some initial resistance, the households proved effective in ending the severe isolation on the part of students. Households remain a cherished tradition today, with more than 900 students belonging to 50 households.
Other resources were spent on campus ministry and student life, as well as youth conferences that also attracted new students. Recruitment targeted young Catholics who were active in the charismatic renewal or who wanted to attend a college dedicated to authentic Catholicism. In time, the entire atmosphere of the College was reformed, in part by the influx of excited new students.
The restoration of campus life meant that other improvements were delayed, and the changes came at a high price. By 1976, the enrollment was so low that some faculty assumed the College’s days were numbered. Others disagreed with Father Scanlan’s program, and many members of the student body, the faculty, and the administration resigned or left for other schools. Some of the administrators chosen to replace them also departed.
Anger was also felt locally and among some alumni when the expenses involved in athletics coupled with low attendance at games prompted the school to abandon its participation in basketball in 1981.
Slowly, Father Scanlan assembled a team that could implement his vision for the school as a place of vigorous Catholicism and academic excellence. The fruits of their efforts were apparent in 1980 when the College earned official designation as the University of Steubenville, through the addition of several graduate programs, including an MBA, MS in Education, and MA in Theology.
In 1985, in recognition of the Catholic Franciscan spirit suffusing the school, the Board of Trustees voted to change the name to Franciscan University of Steubenville. Also in 1985, the Pre-Theologate Program began. At the time, it was a bold experiment that sought to encourage vocations by providing men with a community setting to discern the priesthood and religious life, while they remained fully involved as students. Known today as the Priestly Discernment Program, 115 of the program’s graduates from 2004-2014 alone have entered a seminary or religious order.
By 1983, the University had paid off its entire debt, inaugurating a new era of construction. The John Paul II Library was dedicated in 1987. The next year, the one-time Ohio Valley Skating Rink was purchased and converted into the St. Joseph Center for offices and classrooms. In 1992, the Finnegan Fieldhouse was dedicated, boasting courts for basketball and racquetball, a weight room, and an exercise room.
By 1989, full-time undergraduate student enrollment was 1,179, surpassing at last the previous high set in 1970. The vibrant quality of the faith was also attracting faith-filled Catholic professors who often applied at the encouragement of students or priests returning home from the annual summer Priests’ Conferences held every year since 1975. Father Scanlan interviewed every applicant personally and found scholars who shared his enthusiasm for “dynamic orthodoxy,” an educational approach marked by fidelity to the Church and openness to the Holy Spirit.
In 1989, the members of the theology faculty along with the friars at the University were the very first professors and campus ministers in the United States to publically make the newly formulated Profession of Faith and Oath of Fidelity called for in the revised Code of Canon Law.
In 1991, the University secured the use of a recently restored 650-year-old Carthusian monastery, the Kartause Maria Thronus Iesu (“Monastery of Our Lady, Throne of Jesus”), for students to spend a memorable semester studying in picturesque Gaming, Austria, in the foothills of the Alps. The following year, the University started the Language and Catechetical Institute (LCI) at Gaming to provide desperately needed catechetical training to teachers from Eastern Europe. In 1996, the University helped to launch the International Theological Institute for Studies on Marriage and the Family (ITI) at Gaming.
A capital campaign initiated in 1996 provided funding for SS. Cosmas and Damian Science Hall, the first academic building dedicated to the sciences. Completion of the three-story, 43,000-square-foot building continued the University’s mission to prepare students who are grounded in a reverence for the dignity of human life for careers in medicine and the sciences.
In 1999, Father Scanlan made the decision to step down as president of the University. He was asked by the trustees, however, to serve as chancellor and bore the title president emeritus. Taking the helm of a college in 1974 plagued with debt and lacking spiritual vitality, Father Scanlan was able to bequeath to his successor a university with a world-renowned faculty, a student body of over 2,000, and a tradition of dynamic orthodoxy.